Law Firms · Practical Growth Guide
How to Choose a Law Firm Marketing Agency: Questions to Ask Before Signing
Use a practical scorecard to compare law firm marketing agencies on signed-case measurement, intake, account ownership, compliance, and the first 90 days.

The most revealing question in an agency pitch isn’t “What will my cost per lead be?” It’s “Show me how I’ll know whether the cases we want are signing, and who fixes the problem if they aren’t.”
A marketing agency can buy traffic, build pages, and report inquiries. A law firm still has to decide which matters it wants, get the right people on the phone, and track whether those conversations turn into engagements. If you can’t see what happens between the click and the signed retainer, it’s hard to tell whether to replace the agency, change the campaign, or fix intake.
Here’s how we’d run the selection process if we were sitting on your side of the table.
1. Define the cases you’re buying before you buy the leads
Give each finalist the same brief. Specify the practice area, target markets, what counts as a wanted matter, who qualifies it, and how many additional cases the firm can responsibly handle. A personal injury firm might separate general motor vehicle inquiries from the subset that attorneys actually want. For a firm with several offices, name the locations that can answer promptly and take the matters you want advertised.
Give vendors a de-identified baseline: media spend, agency fees, unique inquiries, contact rate, wanted matters, signed engagements, and how long signups usually take. Label anything you can’t measure. Ask how they would fix missing data without slowing down intake.
Then ask each vendor to recommend what **not** to fund first. A credible answer should follow from your capacity, economics, or measurement gaps. “We’ll run SEO, PPC, and social” is a service list, not a recommendation. For a focused channel comparison, see SEO vs. Google Ads for law firms.
2. Make the agency walk one inquiry all the way through
Skip the dashboard tour. Ask for a demonstration with a fictional lead: click an ad, submit a form, route the inquiry to intake, log attempted and successful contact separately, record disposition, and show where the signed engagement would appear. Ask what happens if that same prospect calls tomorrow from a different number or if a campaign sends an inquiry during a holiday closure.
A useful reporting view shows the path from **unique inquiry → contacted → wanted matter → signed engagement**. It lets you filter by practice area and market and see unknown or unattributed records rather than quietly assigning credit. Agree on a cohort rule, such as inquiry month, and an observation window appropriate to your practice. Don’t compare this week’s inquiries with this week’s signups as though they were the same people.
For example, an illustrative campaign spends $12,000 on media and $4,000 on directly allocated management and other campaign costs. It generates 200 unique inquiries and 10 signed target matters after a consistent follow-up window. Its media cost per inquiry is $60. Its campaign cost per signed target matter is $1,600. Those numbers answer different questions. If another report includes fees or production in one month but not the next, it isn’t a fair comparison either.
Ask who owns each handoff and when they’ll act. If leads aren’t contacted, the firm’s intake manager needs to see it. If intake is fast but leads are rarely wanted, the agency needs to investigate targeting and messaging. Both teams should agree on the outcome and on what counts as evidence. Our personal injury intake scripts guide offers a practical starting point for defining the intake side.
3. Put account control and offboarding in the contract
Your firm should be able to see what it’s paying for and move on without losing its ability to run the practice. Make a simple asset inventory: domain and DNS, site and source files, ad accounts and billing, analytics and conversion configuration, tracking numbers, CRM records, landing pages, creative and licenses. For each, record who holds contractual ownership, who has platform admin access, what is exportable or transferable, and what happens on termination.
Make the distinction between **vendor access** and **firm control** concrete. For instance, Google documents how manager accounts link to individual Google Ads accounts and how manager ownership changes administrative rights. A vendor does not need your personal login to work in an authorized account. Have the firm verify its own access and agree on the minimum roles the agency needs. Designate an internal backup administrator where the platform supports it.
Ask the agency to show a sample transition checklist before signing. It should name the exports and handoff owner, when credentials or access will be revoked, how tracking numbers will be handled, and which third-party licenses or proprietary tools don’t transfer. If something cannot be transferred, price that dependency into the decision rather than discovering it on the last day.
4. Check how the agency handles attorney approval and sensitive information
Ask who in the firm signs off on ads, landing pages, and campaign changes; how that approval is recorded; and what happens if a live ad needs to be pulled. Have designated counsel confirm the applicable jurisdictions’ rules, including any filing requirements, before launch. The ABA’s Model Rule 7.1 addresses misleading communications about legal services, and Model Rule 5.3 addresses supervision of nonlawyer assistance. These are model rules, not substitutes for the rules that govern your firm.
Ask what data flows into ad platforms, analytics, call recording tools, or AI systems. Require a plain-language map that includes subcontractors and retention. Keep identifiable intake and matter details out of demos and routine marketing reports. Do not treat a vendor’s blanket promise of compliance as approval to send information into another system; have the firm review the actual setup and marketplace terms.
5. Score the finalists on evidence, not presentation
Give each finalist the same demo, questions, and scoring rules. Here’s a starting scorecard. Give full points for verified evidence, half for a credible plan with an owner and deadline, and zero for a promise without proof.
| Weight | Criterion | What earns full credit |
|---|---|---|
| 25 | Signed-case measurement | Live walkthrough using a fictional inquiry and a sample cohort report that reconciles spend, lead quality, and signed matters. |
| 20 | Strategy and market fit | A first-90-day plan tied to wanted cases, specific geographies, realistic intake capacity, and a reasoned channel choice. |
| 20 | Account control and exit | Documented firm access and asset ownership, a workable transition checklist, and disclosure of nontransferable assets. |
| 15 | Intake accountability | Named owners, targets for first contact, disposition rules, and a routine for fixing handoff gaps. |
| 10 | Compliance and privacy | Written lawyer approval workflow, named reviewers, and a clear map of data access and vendors. |
| 10 | Commercial terms | A written statement of work that separates media from fees, spells out deliverables, and explains cancellation and transition. |
Set nonnegotiables before scoring. For example: no launch without verified firm access and a named attorney reviewer; no signed-case reporting promise without an agreed way to connect to intake data. A high numerical score shouldn’t cancel out a failed nonnegotiable.
6. Agree on what’s true at 30, 60, and 90 days
At 30 days, the foundation should be inspectable: access confirmed, economics baselined, routing tested, and reporting definitions signed off. At 60 days, review which campaigns produced wanted matters and where follow-up stalled; test one meaningful change at a time. At 90 days, examine mature cohorts and make a documented decision to hold, shift, or scale budget. Longer sales or case-signing cycles may need more time; agree on that before everyone judges results from incomplete data.
If you already have capable vendors but nobody owns the whole funnel, another channel specialist may not be the missing piece. The better first move may be an internal owner, an independent audit, or fractional CMO leadership for the firm. If the problem is clearly execution in one channel and accountability is already in place, hire the specialist.
Before you sign, compare finalists on the same fictional lead, the same scope, and the same definition of a signed case. That comparison will tell you more than a polished forecast. If you’re not sure where the funnel breaks today, start with a Revenue Authority audit so your next agency brief reflects the problem you actually need solved.
Common questions
What should a law firm ask a marketing agency before signing?
Ask which matters it will pursue, how it will measure signed cases, who owns each advertising account and asset, and who is accountable for intake and reporting. Request a walkthrough of one fictional inquiry and a copy of the proposed scope.
Should a law firm own its advertising accounts?
Ask for written terms covering firm-controlled access, billing, campaign history, and what happens during offboarding. Identify agency-owned or nontransferable assets before launch.
How can a law firm compare two proposals fairly?
Use the same target case types, fictional inquiry, and reporting definitions for both. Compare written scope and evidence, not just lead-price estimates or a polished forecast.
Share this guide
FacebookLinkedInPut the plan to work
Connect strategy with hands-on execution.
RevAuth helps law firms, medical providers, and established service businesses improve marketing, conversion, and the systems behind growth.
See if You QualifyRelated services
- Fractional CMO & Marketing Leadership for Law Firms
- Law Firm Intake & Patient Conversion Consulting
- Marketing Attribution & Performance Reporting
Continue reading
- Law Firm CRM vs. Legal Intake Software: What Does Your Firm Actually Need?
- How Much Should a Law Firm Spend on Marketing? A Budget Planning Guide